New Delhi, April 18: The Supreme Court’s dismissal of a petition seeking an independent probe into the death of Judge BH Loya on Thursday evoked sharp reactions from all quarters. At a press conference, BJP spokesperson Sambit Patra said the PIL was actually a “Political Interest Litigation”. He pointed out that the court said that it appeared the PIL was filed over some political rivalry. Also Read - Rift in BJP Ahead of Bengal Elections 2021, Workers Clash at Party Offices, Torch Vehicles
Patra added there couldn’t be a more scathing comment on political parties, and especially Congress chief Rahul Gandhi, who used the court to settle political scores. He said it was a “new low” in Indian politics that the Congress used its “invisible hand” to scheme and plot against the BJP. Rahul should apologise to the nation for making this attempt in dragging the judiciary into this, he said. Also Read - Breaking News: Fire Breaks Out in Delhi's Uttam Nagar, 15 Fire Tenders Rushed to Spot
Speaking next, Gaurav Bhatia said while the verdict also points at certain lawyers who go to court not to practise but to threaten the judge. He said the Congress should now apologise and accept that it made a mistake and also stop character assassination that the party indulged in. Also Read - Mamata's Nephew Abhishek Banerjee Sends Legal Notice to BJP's Suvendu Adhikari
One of the petitioners’ advocates Prashant Bhushan called the judgement a “black day in the history of the judiciary”. He said the court based its judgement on the affidavit of judges but it didn’t take into account the ECG report that rejected the heart attack theory.
Speaking to ANI, petitioner and Congress leader Tehseen Poonawalla said though the Supreme Court verdict is binding on all, “the fact of the matter is whether there were lacunae in the inquiry…and if that has been addressed”.
Meanwhile, Caravan, the magazine that did a series of stories raising doubts over Justice Loya’s death, said it would stand by all its stories. Caravan executive editor Vinod K Jose wrote on his twitter that the “stories speak for itself”.
Earlier in the day, while delivering the judgement, Justice DY Chandrachud had said that political rivalries should be settled outside the court. Judge Loya was trying the Sohrabuddin Sheikh fake encounter case at the time of his death.